Adam has moved in with Jennifer and on top of that, they're engaged. No wedding date has been planned, and no ring has been given yet. Married couple Audrey and Jeff are invited to an art opening and she wants to invite Adam and Jennifer. Audrey says that they don't have any couple friends and Jennifer is like a little sister to her. In addition she wants Jeff to set a good example to them. When they meet, Adam says they compromise, but Jeff says that when they "compromise" Audrey gets her way and this is how things will be with them. Jeff decides to sell Audrey's bike to her dismay and he wants to know why she's upset with him, but she tells him to figure it out. Adam and Jennifer get into a fight, because he feels that he will not have a say in things and Jennifer questions if he wants to marry her and when he hesitates, she's mad and slams the door on him. In the end Adam with help from Jeff, knows how he feels about marrying Jennifer and Jeff, with Jennifer's help, knows why Audrey was mad when he wanted to sell her bike.

Jeff's birthday is coming up and he's less than thrilled that he will have a party. Even though is doesn't want it he'll have one because Audrey wants to do it. In addition it will make her happy, he'll get his birthday deal. Adam wants to know what it is, but Jeff refuses to tell him. Audrey decides to throw a party that she wants, since Jeff doesn't really care what kind of party it is, so she decides to throw one with a Cuban theme. Adam decides that he wants a birthday deal; Jennifer agrees and she would like to have one as well and that nothing will be off limits. Adam feels that the "off limits" part may be something he'll regret. Jeff is gets upset when he discovers that Audrey bought expensive and quality things like champagne and glasses for the party. She tells Jeff that the champagne was for a toast telling everyone that he is a sweet, special generous man he is and she leaves the kitchen upset. Jeff makes amends when he toasts Audrey for the hard work and effort she's done for his party. Jennifer reveals what her birthday deal will be and it isn't as bad as Adam thought it would be and we find out what Jeff's birthday deal is.

Audrey bets Jeff that he can't get a phone number from a younger girl, and gives him a night without his wedding ring to try it.

Adam buys a new video-game which he and Russell can't stop playing. Jennifer discusses with Adam about him spending a lot on stuff for himself now that they are a couple. Audrey gets a promotion but when she tells Jeff he doesn't seem excited about it because the Knicks lost. Jeff invites her to a Knicks game in the VIP section to make things right.

Russell accidentally runs into an older woman from his past named Constance. He then tries to impress her with his physical gifts.

Jeff isn't sure how to explain to Audrey his "excitement" while Jennifer was giving him a massage.

Audrey está desechando una colección de camisetas de Jeff de sus días de escuela secundaria y universidad. Jeff se opone porque representan recuerdos de eventos importantes en su vida. Audrey recoge todas las camisetas de Jeff y hace un edredón con ellas. Jeff inicialmente se opone, pero luego descubre que le gusta, aunque ahora solo se dedica a recordar los buenos tiempos que tuvo. Jennifer convence a Adam de sacar sus cosas del almacenamiento y después de revisar sus cosas, ella piensa que él tiene algo por las chicas polinesias. Audrey le dice que no se preocupe porque él está con ella, pero aún le molesta. La percepción de Russell sobre su nueva novia Jesse es que está obsesionada con el sexo porque todo lo que dice suena así para él, pero pronto comienza a no gustarle porque, mientras ella lo dice, el sexo no está sucediendo.