Carly is a young teenager living in Seattle. When her friend Freddie accidentally leaks a video of her and her best friend Sam onto the Internet, they decide to create an online web show.

Jake Krandle, one of the cutest boys at Ridgeway Middle School breaks up with his girlfriend, and all the girls at school want a piece of him. Carly thinks she'll get just that when she invites him on her web-show to perform some songs he wrote. But during a rehearsal, Jake is found to be a horrible singer, and Carly has to struggle to convince an already jealous Freddie to digitally enhance his voice.

Nevel Papperman is back, and instead of trashing iCarly in his articles, he has directly sabotaged the website itself. Meanwhile Spencer persuades the Plain White T's to perform on Carly's show as a favor for preventing lead singer Tom Higgenson from being hit by a falling sign at the mall. But how do they expect the band to perform on a show nobody can see?

For the science project, Carly and Sam choose to raise chicks, and they have to search the apartment frantically when they hatch sooner than anyone expected.

On the fifth anniversary of their friendship, Carly gives Sam a one-of-a-kind iCarly T-Shirt as a gift. Desperate for an attempt to return the favor, Sam tries to buy a pair of hard-to-find concert tickets for Carly's favorite band from a scalper. With no other means to purchase the tickets, she sells him the shirt and puts both Carly's show and their friendship at risk.

Carly y la campeona de artes marciales Shelby Marx (interpretada por Victoria Justice de Zoey 101 y Spectacular!) acuerdan tener una pelea de exhibición benéfica después de que Carly la desafía en tono de broma. Desafortunadamente, Carly cae accidentalmente sobre la abuela de Shelby durante una rueda de prensa. Pensando que Shelby quiere vengarse, Carly se retira de la pelea, solo para ser ridiculizada como una cobarde. Carly visita a Shelby y se disculpa, y la pelea vuelve a estar en marcha. Sin embargo, Nevel Papperman altera un clip de la rueda de prensa para hacer parecer que Carly derribó intencionalmente a la abuela de Shelby para engañar a Shelby y hacerla pelear con Carly. Shelby, furiosa, ataca a Carly de verdad durante la pelea, y Carly luego sostiene la pierna de Shelby durante el resto de la "pelea".